When Manchester United lost to Newcastle at the weekend, Sir Alex refuted the suggestions of a panic situation in the Manchester United camp. And on the face of it, the denial seems to be justified. After all, they are just 3 points off the pace in the league, still in the thick of the two-horse race for the Premier League title. But deep down Sir Alex knows that the situation is not what it should have been.
Last season, when Manchester United won the record 19th title, everyone agreed to an extent that this title was not won because of Manchester United being stronger or better, but because of the challenging teams not being up to the mark. Back then, Manchester City were not as experienced, Chelsea were going through an extremely bad patch and Arsenal were in shambles as usual. The shortcomings of their squad were rather cruelly highlighted in the Champions League final at Wembley where they succumbed to a 3-1 defeat at the hands of Barcelona. It was clearly evident that midfield reinforcements were required post Paul Scholes’ retirement. Somehow, Sir Alex chose not to invest in the midfield position and decided to go the Wenger way of promoting youth. A choice not turning out to be a wise one at the moment.
After Paul Scholes’ retirement and Darren Fletcher’s forced exile from football, Sir Alex opted for the central midfield pairing of Tom Cleverly and Anderson. Although the pair worked well in the opening matches, injuries have caused a rather precarious midfielder shortage at the club, a situation which ideally should have been handled in the summer transfer window itself. Had United completed the signings of a proper central midfielder and a defensive midfielder instead of signing a winger and a defender, their position might have been much stronger.
The winter transfer window presents the perfect opportunity for Sir Alex, to correct these mistakes. First and foremost United need to buy a proper defensive midfielder. Carrick’s failed auditions in this position should signal a move for Danielle De Rossi. Although people may argue that Phil Jones seems more than capable of playing as a central midfielder, he is first and foremost a central defender and should be seen as a long term replacement for Rio Ferdinand rather than Roy Keane’s reincarnation. Central Attacking midfield is a position where United can afford to risk not buying a player. With Tom Cleverly returning from injury, this position can be taken care of. Also Wayne Rooney may also enjoy playing in this position as it will allow him a greater chance to roam across the pitch and pick holes in opposition defence. Next up, a left back. Patrice Evra has been distinctly average for a couple of seasons now and his deputies, Da Silva twins are more often than not in the treatment room. United needs to buy a good solid left back and ask Patrice Evra to move on. Leighton Baines, anyone.
Recent return of Paul Scholes to the squad can at best be described as a move to paper over the cracks. He still has the awareness and vision, if not the legs to compete at the highest level. He managed to complete 71 passes while playing just 35 minutes during his return to the pitch against Manchester City, i.e. more passes than any other player on the pitch during the entire game. But if he found it hard to complete 90 minutes during the last season, it is debatable how he could cope with it this time around.
At the time of writing this article Sir Alex has rejected the idea of signing any player during the winter transfer window, a decision which might backfire in case of any further injuries to Phil Jones or Carrick. The squad is threadbare at the moment and Paul Scholes will certainly not solve the problem. Maybe Sneijder or De Rossi will.